WRONG
Do Cougars Exist?

Continue reading:
"Do Cougars Exist?" ››
Permalink | Recommend to a Friend | Comments (73)
Score: 14 (20 votes cast)
How Do You Lose Weight? Which Diet Is The Best?

Continue reading:
"How Do You Lose Weight? Which Diet Is The Best?" ››
Permalink | Recommend to a Friend | Comments (25)
Score: 23 (25 votes cast)
Should School Start Later?
so let me get this straight: you want me to start eating wormsContinue reading:
"Should School Start Later?" ››
Permalink | Recommend to a Friend | Comments (20)
Score: 18 (18 votes cast)
Are Women Prone To Paranormal Beliefs?
you have a better explanation?Continue reading:
"Are Women Prone To Paranormal Beliefs?" ››
Permalink | Recommend to a Friend | Comments (38)
Score: 20 (26 votes cast)
Another Diagnosis Of Schizophrenia, This Time With Cats

Continue reading:
"Another Diagnosis Of Schizophrenia, This Time With Cats" ››
Permalink | Recommend to a Friend | Comments (29)
Score: 17 (17 votes cast)
Are Certain Behaviors-- And Jobs-- More Masculine? And Out Of Our Control?
wouldn't you know it, all the best derivatives traders are lesbiansContinue reading:
"Are Certain Behaviors-- And Jobs-- More Masculine? And Out Of Our Control?" ››
Permalink | Recommend to a Friend | Comments (17)
Score: 22 (24 votes cast)
There Is No Link Between ADHD And Organophosphate Pesticides
come on you guys: what do the authors want to be true?Continue reading:
"There Is No Link Between ADHD And Organophosphate Pesticides" ››
Permalink | Recommend to a Friend | Comments (49)
Score: 24 (26 votes cast)
Study Finds Chocolate Causes Depression. In Other News, These Kinds Of Studies Cause Insanity

Continue reading:
"Study Finds Chocolate Causes Depression. In Other News, These Kinds Of Studies Cause Insanity" ››
Permalink | Recommend to a Friend | Comments (39)
Score: 23 (25 votes cast)
"She Said She Had Breast Cancer-- But She Lied"

Continue reading:
""She Said She Had Breast Cancer-- But She Lied"" ››
Permalink | Recommend to a Friend | Comments (104)
Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
Medical Bankruptcies, Redux
Continue reading:
"Medical Bankruptcies, Redux" ››
Permalink | Recommend to a Friend
Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
Fearless Kids Go On To Become Criminals

Continue reading:
"Fearless Kids Go On To Become Criminals" ››
Permalink | Recommend to a Friend | Comments (29)
Score: 2 (2 votes cast)
More On Amygdala, Anxiety, and MRIs
Then I opened my mail.
Continue reading:
"More On Amygdala, Anxiety, and MRIs" ››
Permalink | Recommend to a Friend | Comments (16)
Score: 2 (2 votes cast)
It's Not A Lie If It's True
Continue reading:
"It's Not A Lie If It's True" ››
Permalink | Recommend to a Friend | Comments (8)
Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
Merck Publishes A Fake Journal
Continue reading:
"Merck Publishes A Fake Journal" ››
Permalink | Recommend to a Friend | Comments (9)
Score: 1 (1 votes cast)
Is A Brain Glitch To Blame For Financial Crisis?
Continue reading:
"Is A Brain Glitch To Blame For Financial Crisis?" ››
Permalink | Recommend to a Friend | Comments (21)
Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
To The Brain, God Is Just Another Guy
The most important question about any scientific study, that must be answered before any others are asked:
What do they want to be true?
Continue reading:
"To The Brain, God Is Just Another Guy" ››
Permalink | Recommend to a Friend | Comments (23)
Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
What Happens To Fake Studies?
Continue reading:
"What Happens To Fake Studies?" ››
Permalink | Recommend to a Friend | Comments (17)
Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
Christopher Columbus Was Wrong
Continue reading:
"Christopher Columbus Was Wrong" ››
Permalink | Recommend to a Friend | Comments (44)
Score: 1 (1 votes cast)
The Media Is The Message, And The Message Is You're An Idiot

You mean I get to pick?
Continue reading:
"The Media Is The Message, And The Message Is You're An Idiot" ››
Permalink | Recommend to a Friend | Comments (11)
Score: 1 (1 votes cast)
Either Conservatives Are Cowards Or Liberals Are...
A news story, talked about ad nauseam, concerning a study in Science that no one will bother to read.
Subjects-- liberals and conservatives-- are shown random pictures of scary stuff (spider on a person's face) interspersed between photos of neutral stuff (bunnies.) Conservatives exhibit much more fear (e.g. startle response, skin response) than liberals.
In case the political implications of this study are not obvious, these are the titles of the news reports about the study:
- Science News: The Politics of Fear
- Slate: Republicans Are From Mars, Liberals Are From Venus
- Scientific American: Are you more likely to be politically left or right if you scare easily?
- Freakonomics blog: Don't scream, you'll give your ideals away
Etc. The message is clear: conservatives get scared more easily than liberals.
Right? That's what the titles say-- I'm not off base here, right? There's no other possible way to interpret them?
II.
The methodology is fine-- but the interpretation is so demonstrably flawed that they are actually interpreting the results backwards.
Here's the most important line of all-- found only in the SA article-- in the second to last paragraph, of course:
People who leaned more politically left didn't respond any differently to those [scary] images than they did to pictures of a bowl of fruit, a rabbit or a happy child.
Really? Spider on face vs. happy child? No difference?
That extra bit of info doesn't even appear in the Science News story-- or anywhere else, for that matter.

The graph shows that liberals and conservatives have a trivial skin response to neutral pictures, and liberals show no difference in response when confronted with a scary photo.
So the actual finding isn't that conservatives are fearful; it's that liberals seem not to exhibit much response to scary photos.
III.
But it's actually a little worse than that.
The typical use for such tests of startle and fear aren't to see how scared people are, they are used specifically to find out how scared people aren't. For example, they are used to evaluate psychopathy, and the results are the same as here-- psychopaths have decreased responses, compared to normal people, to aversive photos.
So which is it? Are conservatives fearful, or are liberals psychopaths?
I'm not picking sides in the debate, but I am pointing out how this study missed the actual result-- liberals are less fearful than would be expected-- and then the study was publicized in the media with an entirely backwards inference, that conservatives scare easily.
But it sounds like science, conducted by scientists; it's published in Science, and then publicized in Scientific American. It must be true.
(more)
Continue reading:
"Either Conservatives Are Cowards Or Liberals Are..." ››
Permalink | Recommend to a Friend | Comments (19)
Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
For more articles check out the Archives Web page ››